Investigations and Actions


《中国科技期刊研究》一论文数据异常

近日的一项调查显示,发表在《中国科技期刊研究》的一篇论文《AI辅助工具的应用与科技期刊编辑职业压力的关联-基于问卷调查的实证分析存在数据异常。


Questionable Authorship in 10.3389/fpubh.2026.1774267

The authorship of the article is questionable.


Abnormal Data in 10.1038/s41565-025-02082-0

Recently, the 5GH Team received a message alleging the data reported in an article may be manipulated. After the investigation, we found some anomalous data in the article.


Problematic References in 10.1016/j.aej.2025.06.053

Several problematic references were found on this article.


Chinese Articles in PLoS Have a Citation Disadvantage

An investigation by the 5GH Team reveals that PLoS articles with a Chinese first author have citation disadvantage.


Chinese Articles Receive High Citations in Nature Communications, Science Advances, and PNAS, but not in PLoS ONE or Scientific Reports

Nature communications articles with a Chinese first author published in 2025 received an average of 13.4 citations, ranking 1st among the nation published more than 20 articles in the journal


Over 60% Advanced Materials Articles Were from China

Our investigation reveals that about 61% Advanced Materials articles published in 2025 have a Chinese first author.


Chinese Authors Are Over Represented in Advanced Materials Family

Our investigation reveals that Chinese authors are over represented in Advanced Materials family. In 2025, about 61% published in Advanced Materials have a Chinese first author. The number reaches 71.6% in Advanced Functional Materials.


Comment on 10.1038/s44360-026-00149-3

Concerns are raised regarding the article


Comment on 10.1186/s12985-023-02144-6

Concerns are raised regarding the article


China Ranks among the Top Collaborating Countries for US Universities

An investigation by the 5GH Team found that China ranks among the top collaborating countries for U.S. universities.


Comment on 10.1186/s12889-025-25843-x

The article suggests that a structured after-school physical activity program can effectively improve physical fitness, body composition, and sleep of primary school students. This finding is interesting not only to the scientific community, but also to the general public, as physical inactivity and declining physical fitness pose significant risks to the health of Chinese children and adolescents. However, caution is needed when we interpret the results from this study.


Salami Slicing Publication Practices by a Group from Liaoning Normal University

A recent investigation reveals that an author group from Liaoning Normal University with core authors of ZHU Xingchen (朱星辰) exhibits several salami-slicing publication practices.


Questionable Ethical Approval Number in Three Articles


An Author Group from Xihua University Published 9 Articles on Secondary Analysis of the China General Social Survey in a Single Year

Slicing publication practices raise debate within the scientific community. Some argue that such practices may cause fragmentation of academic research and waste the time of reviewers and readers. Moreover, these practices are believed to boost publication numbers rather than contribute meaningfully to the scientific community.




Previous Page: >>>

Next Page: >>>